Care home and housing near Potton Hall for All rejected on appeal

Potton Hall for Allplaceholder image
Potton Hall for All

A project to build eight houses and a care home close to a community centre in Potton has been rejected on appeal.

The decision leaves a separate application for just the care home still to be decided by Central Bedfordshire Council’s development management committee.

Applicant Aspire LPP submitted full plans for a 67-bedroom care home and eight properties, with parking, on land south of Hutchinson Rise.

The proposals were refused by the committee, which opted to ignore a recommendation of approval by a CBC planning officer.

The application site is within the settlement envelope of Potton and is identified for employment, according to the committee report in July.

“There’s a demand for residential accommodation for older people, including care homes in the surrounding area,” said the report. “CBC will support housing when it’s proportionate to the scale of the settlement.

“No harm has been identified with respect to impacts upon the character and appearance of the area, to the amenities of neighbouring residents, or to highway safety.

“Concerns have been raised with respect to impacts on the proposed future residents of these homes from the nearby Potton Hall for All and potential impacts on the running of this premises.

“But it’s considered, subject to a condition to ensure future residents are protected adequately from noise arising from the hall, there wouldn’t be unreasonable planning restrictions placed on that building.

“Mitigation methods are to include acoustic fencing and adequate glazing specifications and ventilation.”

An appeal was subsequently lodged, but has been dismissed by planning inspector Laura Bartle. “I’ve found that in considering the issues cumulatively, there’s insufficient evidence to show that all living environments would be satisfactory,” she explained.

“The appellant doesn’t dispute that, even with the proposed mitigation, background noise may at times be exceeded at locations within the site. This would result in Potton Hall for All being in breach of conditions 12 and 13 of its planning permission.

“The proposal is contrary to local policies, which seek to secure a satisfactory quality of life for future residents of new properties and to ensure that current nearby uses aren’t adversely affected to an unacceptable degree.”

Council leader and Independent Potton councillor Adam Zerny said in a statement last summer: “It’s not appropriate for housing to be built so close to a new community hall.

“This adjacent sight had planning permission for light industrial. Times will arise when there’s noise around the venue. The number of houses isn’t the issue, it’s the proximity.”

Planning director at Aspire LPP Ryan NIcholls had told the committee: “Extensive work has been done by the applicant to assess the noise impact on the housing.

“With the acoustic glazing and fence, there’ll be sufficient protection from noise levels,” he said.

The application for only the care home was submitted in October. Councillor Zerny added on social media: “I understand Anglian Water raised issues about the smell from the nearby waste treatment plant, next to The Hollow.

“I’d expect the applicant to be asked to consider proposing some mitigation around this.”

News you can trust since 1891
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice